How-to
How to Find an Independent Insurance Broker in 7 Steps
Quick Summary
An independent insurance broker works with many insurance carriers, so they can compare plans from different companies, while a captive agent sells only one company's products. Confirm a broker's state license, ask which carriers they represent, and ask how they are paid before you commit.
- Independent brokers can compare plans from multiple carriers, while captive agents sell only one company's products.
- Check any broker's license with your state's insurance department; in Michigan, that is DIFS.
- Ask which carriers the broker represents before committing to them.
- Ask how the broker is paid: commission, fee, or a mix of both.
Table of Contents
- Independent Insurance Broker vs. Captive Agent: Why the Difference Matters
- Step 1: Decide Which Coverage Lines You Need Help With
- Step 2: Search for Brokers Who Work Across Multiple Carriers
- Step 3: Check an Insurance Broker's License Through Michigan's Department of Insurance and Financial Services
- Step 4: Ask the Right Questions Before You Commit
- Step 5: Understand How Brokers Are Paid
- Step 6: Compare Quotes Side by Side Before You Decide
- Booking Your Free Consultation With McCullough Agency
- Frequently Asked Questions
Independent Insurance Broker vs. Captive Agent: Why the Difference Matters
Last Updated: November 4, 2026
Choosing the right person to help you with insurance can shape your coverage for years. If you're searching for an independent insurance broker, the first question to answer is how they differ from the agent who works for a single company. This confusion comes up often with families and individuals turning 65 or losing employer coverage.
An independent insurance broker works with many insurance carriers. A captive agent represents one company only. That single difference changes what you're offered, what you can compare, and how the advice you get is shaped.
- Independent broker: Can compare plans from multiple carriers and recommend the best fit.
- Captive agent: Can only sell the products of the company they represent.
This doesn't mean captive agents are bad. Many know their company's products very well. But if you only hear one company's options, you may never learn about a better fit somewhere else.
Watch out: Some people assume every broker shops the whole market. Ask directly which carriers they represent before you commit.
Step 1: Decide Which Coverage Lines You Need Help With
Before you search, list the types of insurance you need help with. Health, Medicare, life, and property and casualty insurance each have different rules and different carriers. A broker who is strong in one area may not be the best choice for another.
Write down your situation first:
- Are you turning 65 or enrolling in Medicare?
- Are you self-employed and shopping on the ACA Marketplace?
- Do you need life insurance to protect family members?
- Do you own a home, rental property, or a business?
Matching your needs to a broker's focus saves time. It also helps you ask better questions when you start to compare options.
Step 2: Search for Brokers Who Work Across Multiple Carriers
Start your search with brokers who say they work with several carriers. Look for clear language about which companies they represent.
A few quick checks can help you narrow your list:
- Do they name the carriers they work with?
- Do they explain their process without pushing one product?
- Do they serve customers in your state?
A common mistake is choosing the first broker who appears in a search. Take time to review at least three options before deciding. You can also ask friends, family members, or your employer's benefits team for referrals.
Step 3: Check an Insurance Broker's License Through Michigan's Department of Insurance and Financial Services
Every legitimate insurance broker and agent needs a state license, and you can confirm that license yourself in a few minutes. In Michigan, the regulator is the Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services (DIFS), which maintains licensing records you can search.
Here is how to verify a broker:
- Get the broker's full legal name and, if available, their National Producer Number (NPN). The NPN is a unique identifier assigned through the National Insurance Producer Registry (NIPR) and is printed on most agent business cards and email signatures.
- Search the DIFS license lookup tool by name or NPN.
- Confirm the license status is active and that the lines of authority match what you need, for example, life and health versus property and casualty.
- Review any disciplinary actions or enforcement records listed, and read the disposition rather than just the presence of a record.
Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services licensee search
A license alone does not guarantee good service, but it confirms the broker meets state requirements and gives you a paper trail if something goes wrong.
Watch out: A license lookup confirms standing, not competence. A broker can be fully licensed and still be a poor fit for your coverage line, so pair the license check with the questions in the next step.
For a deeper vetting angle, ask the broker which specific carriers they are appointed with for your coverage type.
Step 4: Ask the Right Questions Before You Commit
Once you have a short list, schedule a conversation. A good broker will welcome questions. Bring a list so you cover the basics.
Schedule a free consultation →
Useful questions include:
- Which carriers do you represent for my type of coverage?
- How do you decide which plan to recommend?
- Will I have one main contact, or will I speak with different staff?
- How do you help with changes, renewals, and claims?
- Are you licensed in my state for the lines I need?
Pay attention to how the broker answers. Clear, patient answers are a good sign. Pressure to decide quickly is a warning sign.

Step 5: Understand How Brokers Are Paid
Brokers are paid in different ways, including commissions from the insurance carrier, fees from the client, or a mix of both. Knowing which applies to you helps you judge whether advice is balanced.
- Commission-based: The carrier pays the broker when you buy a policy, typically as a percentage of premium that varies by carrier and product line. You often pay no direct fee, but the commission can differ between carriers, which is why transparency matters.
- Fee-based: You pay the broker directly for advice or service, which can reduce dependence on carrier commissions but adds an out-of-pocket cost.
- Mixed: Some brokers charge fees for certain services and earn commissions on policies, so ask which parts of your relationship are fee-paid and which are commission-paid.
Ask every broker how they are paid, and ask them to put it in writing. A transparent broker will explain this without hesitation.
Ask whether the broker is fee-only, fee-based, or commission-based, and whether they will disclose how they are compensated. Fee-only brokers generally do not earn carrier commissions, and commission-based brokers earn them from the carrier.
Brokers are paid in different ways, so the table below sums up how each model works.
| Pay model | Who pays the broker | Key point |
|---|---|---|
| Commission-based | The insurance carrier | Often no direct fee; commission varies by carrier |
| Fee-based | The client | Reduces reliance on carrier commissions; adds a cost |
| Mixed | Client and carrier | Ask which services are fee-paid and which are commission-paid |
Step 6: Compare Quotes Side by Side Before You Decide
Once you have options, compare them carefully. Look beyond the monthly premium. Check deductibles, out-of-pocket maximums, provider networks, prescription coverage, and any gaps in protection.
Create a simple comparison list:
- Monthly premium
- Deductible and out-of-pocket maximum
- Network or provider rules
- Prescription drug coverage (if applicable)
- Service and support options
A lower premium can mean higher costs when you actually need care.
Booking Your Free Consultation With McCullough Agency
If you're ready to talk through your options, McCullough Agency offers a free consultation. We're an independent, locally owned agency across Medicare, health, life, and property and casualty insurance. Our goal is to explain your choices clearly so you can decide with confidence.
Before you schedule, have your current coverage details, your questions, and your timeline ready. That helps us focus on what matters most to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an independent insurance broker? An independent insurance broker works with multiple insurance carriers. This lets them compare plans from different companies and recommend options that fit your needs and budget.
How do I check if an insurance broker is licensed? Use your state's insurance department lookup tool. In Michigan, that is the Department of Insurance and Financial Services. Confirm the license is active and covers the coverage type you need.
Is an independent broker better than a captive agent? It depends on your needs. Independent brokers can compare many carriers, while captive agents offer one company's products. Independent brokers may offer more choices, but both can be good options.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it better to go through an independent insurance agent?
Often, yes, if you want choices. An independent broker places your coverage with several insurance carriers, so they can compare options across companies instead of selling only one company's products. A captive agent represents a single insurer. Independent brokers are not automatically cheaper or better, though, so compare the coverage, the price and the service you receive before deciding.
How can I check whether an insurance broker is licensed?
Michigan's Department of Insurance and Financial Services maintains licensing records you can search. Ask the broker for their license number and confirm the license is active and covers the lines of insurance you need. A legitimate broker will give you their license number without hesitation.
Is it cheaper to go through an insurance broker?
A broker does not necessarily lower your premium, because most brokers are paid by the carrier through commissions built into the price. What a broker can do is compare multiple carriers for you, which sometimes uncovers a better price or coverage. Pricing depends on your age, location, coverage needs and the carriers available, so ask for side-by-side quotes before assuming either way.
How many insurance quotes should I compare?
Three to five quotes is a practical range for most people. That is enough to see how prices and coverage differ without overwhelming yourself. Make sure each quote uses the same coverage limits, deductibles and terms so the comparison is fair. Call McCullough Agency to schedule a free consultation if you want help lining them up.