blog
Is WMI Advisors or Planiv the Better Choice for You?
Last Updated: November 12, 2026
Quick Summary
The article cannot verify a direct side-by-side profile of wmi advisors vs planiv from reliable sources, so it recommends checking each firm's Form ADV in the SEC's public database. The right choice depends on comparing fee model, fiduciary standing, and total annual cost.
- Check each firm's Form ADV, especially Part 2A, through the SEC's public Investment Adviser database.
- Normalize both options to total annual dollars paid for the same household scenario.
- Confirm in writing whether the firm acts as a fiduciary at all times.
- Ask whether fund expense ratios and custodial fees are included in the quoted fee.
- Determine whether each name is an advisory firm, a planning software product, or both.
Table of Contents
- What WMI Advisors and Planiv Actually Are
- Side-by-Side Costs and Account Minimums
- Service Model and Fiduciary Relationship
- Feature Comparison Using the Same Scenarios
- Which Option Fits an Individual Planner
- Choosing Planning Software as a Professional Advisor
- Booking Your Next Step With McCullough Agency
- Frequently Asked Questions
What WMI Advisors and Planiv Actually Are
Choosing between WMI Advisors and Planiv starts with knowing what each name actually refers to.
The honest answer is that our research could not verify a direct, side-by-side profile of WMI Advisors and Planiv from current, reliable sources. Securities and Exchange Commission, which is publicly searchable at SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure database.
A Form ADV tells you what a firm does, how it charges, and whether it has disciplinary history, more than most marketing pages. Read Part 2A, which describes services and fees in plain language.
Side-by-Side Costs and Account Minimums
Cost is the first thing most people want to compare, and where marketing claims mislead most. The problem with comparing these options is that they may not sit in the same cost category. Comparing an AUM fee to a software subscription is apples to oranges unless you normalize both to one number: total annual dollars paid for the same scope of work.

The four cost models you will actually encounter
Nearly every advisory or planning option in the United States prices itself one of four ways. Identify which model each name uses before you compare a single number.
- Assets under management (AUM) percentage. A common retail advisory model: an annual percentage of managed assets, billed quarterly in arrears, often with breakpoints that lower the rate as the balance grows. The percentage is the easy part, the breakpoint schedule is where firms differ.
- Flat or retainer fee. A fixed annual or monthly dollar amount, quoted in USD, regardless of portfolio size. This favors larger households, because the fee does not scale with assets.
- Subscription or software fee. A per-user or per-household monthly or annual charge for planning software, sometimes tiered by features or connected accounts. Most planning platforms use this model.
Normalize both options to one number
Build a single comparison row for each option using the same hypothetical household, for example, a $750,000 investable portfolio, two earners, and a need for retirement income and tax planning. Then fill in:
- The advisory or subscription fee in USD per year at that balance.
- Any account minimum, stated in USD, and whether it is a hard minimum or a soft guideline.
- Whether the quoted fee is inclusive or exclusive of underlying fund expense ratios and custodial charges.
- Any one-time onboarding, planning, or termination fee.
- The all-in annual cost as a percentage of the $750,000 portfolio.
That fifth line is the only number that lets you compare an AUM fee against a subscription honestly. Same household, very different cost, and very different service scope, which is why the next section matters as much as this one.
Where the real numbers live: Form ADV
You do not have to rely on a sales page for fee and minimum disclosures. Any firm registered with the SEC as an investment adviser must file Form ADV, which is publicly searchable through the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure database at SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure database. Two items answer most cost questions directly:
- Item 5 of Part 1A discloses the fee structures the firm uses and whether it charges performance-based fees.
- Part 2A, the firm brochure, describes fees, billing timing, account minimums, and other costs in plain language, and Item 5 of Part 2A specifically covers fees and compensation.
If a name in your comparison is a state-registered adviser, the same Form ADV is filed with the state securities regulator and is still searchable through the same database.
Watch out: a quoted percentage that excludes fund expense ratios and custodial fees can understate your all-in cost by a meaningful margin, so ask for the total in dollars, not just the advisory rate.
A cost checklist you can send to both firms
- Fee model (AUM percentage with breakpoints, flat, subscription, or hourly)
- Exact rate or dollar amount at a $750,000 portfolio, quoted in USD
- Hard account minimum, in USD, and whether it can be waived
Request a written quote from both before you decide, and treat any third-party figure as a starting point rather than a fact.
Service Model and Fiduciary Relationship
The relationship between you and an advisor matters as much as the price. Some firms are registered advisory firms that owe a fiduciary duty, while some planning products provide tools without individualized advice. Those are not competing services, they are different categories, and treating them as interchangeable is the most common mistake in this comparison.
The three service models to distinguish
Before comparing fiduciary language, sort each name into one of three buckets:
- Human advice with ongoing management. A registered investment adviser manages assets, delivers a financial plan, and meets with you on a schedule. The firm is typically a fiduciary.
- Human advice on a project or hourly basis. A planner delivers a defined deliverable, a retirement income plan, a tax projection, a second opinion, for a stated fee, with or without ongoing management.
- Software or self-directed planning tools. The product provides modeling, account aggregation, and projections; you supply the judgment. There may be no individualized advice and therefore no advisory fiduciary relationship, even if the company markets planning capabilities.
A name can span more than one bucket, which is why you should ask each firm to describe, in writing, what it will actually do for you month to month.
What 'fiduciary' actually means under U.S. law
The word gets used loosely, so anchor it to the actual standards:
- Registered investment advisers owe a fiduciary duty under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 and comparable state statutes. The SEC's standard for retail advice, summarized in Regulation Best Interest and the agency's investor bulletins, requires advisers to put the client's interest first and disclose conflicts.
- Broker-dealers are held to Regulation Best Interest, which requires recommendations to be in the retail customer's best interest but is not the same ongoing fiduciary duty an adviser owes. A firm can be dually registered and wear both hats depending on the account.
- Software providers generally are not fiduciaries at all, and they may be vendors selling a tool.
Ask each firm two precise questions: whether it acts as a fiduciary at all times or only for certain accounts, and whether that duty covers every recommendation, including rollover recommendations. The answers are usually in Part 2A of Form ADV, Item 4 (advisory business) and Item 5 (fees), plus Item 10 (other financial industry activities and affiliations) and Item 11 (code of ethics and conflicts).
How to read the disclosures yourself
Pull each firm's Form ADV through the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure database at SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure database and read four items:
- Item 4, Advisory business: what services the firm actually provides and how long it has done so.
- Item 5, Fees and compensation: how it is paid, which tells you what incentives it has.
- Item 10, Affiliations: whether it is tied to a broker-dealer, insurer, or product sponsor.
If a name in your comparison has no Form ADV, ask the firm to explain its registration status.
Who you actually work with day to day
Continuity matters as much as the standard. Ask each firm who your named point of contact will be, how often you will hear from them, and what happens if that person leaves.
Watch out: a firm can advertise a fiduciary standard while routing you into accounts or products where a different, weaker standard applies, so confirm in writing which standard covers the specific account you will open.
A service-model checklist to send to both firms
- Is the firm a registered investment adviser, a broker-dealer, a software vendor, or some combination?
- Does it act as a fiduciary at all times, or only for certain accounts?
- Does the fiduciary duty extend to rollover recommendations?
Confirm the scope of services in writing before you commit. A fiduciary title alone does not describe what you will receive.
Feature Comparison Using the Same Scenarios
Software and planning tools vary widely, so it helps to compare them using the same realistic scenarios. Test each option against the same questions:
- Can it model retirement income under a few different market return assumptions?
- Does it handle tax-aware withdrawal planning for accounts that are taxed differently?
- Can you link accounts from multiple custodians into one view?
- How does it treat estate planning goals and beneficiary changes?
Run the same inputs through each platform where you have access, and note where results differ. Many advisors also offer a sample plan or demonstration, letting you judge usability and output quality before signing an agreement.
Which Option Fits an Individual Planner
If you are an individual looking for personal guidance, you likely want a clear fee, a fiduciary commitment, and an advisor who explains tradeoffs without jargon.
A practical way to decide:
- If you want full-service planning with ongoing check-ins, prioritize the service model and the named advisor.
- If you prefer to manage investments yourself and want planning tools, weigh the software and subscription cost more heavily.
- If your situation is complex, with business interests, rental property, or insurance needs across several areas, ask how each firm coordinates those pieces.
Many families benefit from pairing investment planning with protection planning. Life, health, and property coverage can shape how much risk your investments need to carry, so review those decisions alongside any advisory relationship.
Choosing Planning Software as a Professional Advisor
If you are a professional advisor choosing a planning platform, the decision centers on integration, client experience, and cost per user.
Before you commit, also weigh the provider behind the tool. Our explainer on Independent Broker vs Captive Agent: Which Fits You walks through how those structures affect the options you see.
When evaluating your own professional support network, a practical checklist helps. Our guide on How to Choose a Health Insurance Broker in Michigan outlines what to verify, from licensing to how the broker is paid.
Booking Your Next Step With McCullough Agency
If you are weighing these options and want help sorting through your insurance and protection needs, McCullough Agency can help you think it through. You can review our individual and family health insurance services to see how we approach coverage for households in Michigan.
We are a locally owned, independent agency, so our recommendations are not tied to a single carrier. Our team works one on one with clients to match coverage to real budgets and needs.
Schedule a free consultation with McCullough Agency to talk through your situation and get clear answers before you decide.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between WMI Advisors and Planiv?
The two names are often confused because both appear in searches about financial planning, but they serve different roles. Before comparing them, confirm which firm or product you are evaluating, since one may be an advisory practice and the other a planning platform or service provider. Check each company's current website for its services, fee structure and whether it acts as a fiduciary. Pricing and minimums change, so request a current written fee schedule from each before deciding.
How do WMI Advisors and Planiv compare on features?
A fair comparison runs both options through the same scenario: a retirement income projection, a tax-aware withdrawal plan and an estate update. Compare how each handles scenario analysis, account aggregation, client portal access and how easy it is to revise assumptions. Ask for a live demo or sample report. Features that look similar on a product page often differ in depth once you test them with your own numbers.
How much do WMI Advisors and Planiv cost?
Costs depend on the service model, account size and whether you pay an advisory fee, a subscription or a flat planning fee. Neither firm's current rates are verified here, so do not rely on figures from third-party sites. Ask each provider for its full fee schedule, any account minimums and what is included at each tier. Compare total annual cost, not just the headline rate.
Which option is better for an individual planner versus a professional advisor?
An individual usually needs a clear, client-facing plan, easy onboarding and limited administration, while a professional advisor needs practice management, CRM and custodian integration, and reporting for many clients. Decide which profile you match, then weigh each option's ease of use, customization and data security against that need. A tool that suits one profile may not suit the other.